import System.Collections.Generic;

var setupController : SetUpController;

var allPlayers = new List.<GameObject>();
var townspeoplePlayers = new List.<GameObject>();
var maffiaPlayers = new List.<GameObject>();

var isMaffiaVote : boolean;

private var window = Rect(50, 50, 100, 100);
private var window2 = Rect(50, 50, 100, 100);


function Start() {

    setupController = GameObject.Find("Name").GetComponent("SetUpController");

}

function Update(){

    allPlayers = setupController.allPlayersList;

    maffiaPlayers = setupController.mafiaList;

    townspeoplePlayers = setupController.townspeopleList;

}

function OnGUI ()
{
    if (isMaffiaVote){
       GUILayout.FlexibleSpace();
       window = GUILayout.Window (5, window, MafiaVoteWindow, "Mafia Vote");
    }

    else{
       window2 = GUILayout.Window (4, window2, AllVoteWindow, "Vote");
    }
}

function AllVoteWindow (id2 : int) {
    if (!isMaffiaVote){
       GUILayout.BeginVertical();

       for (var ap in allPlayers)
       {
         if (GUILayout.Button(ap.name))
         {

         }
       }
       GUILayout.FlexibleSpace();
       GUILayout.EndVertical();
}
}

function MafiaVoteWindow (id : int) {
    if (isMaffiaVote){
       GUILayout.BeginVertical();

       for (var tpp in townspeoplePlayers)
       {
         if (GUILayout.Button(tpp.name))
         {

         }
       }
       GUILayout.FlexibleSpace();
       GUILayout.EndVertical();
}
}

Both GUI windows are showing up at the same time whether or not "isMafiaVote" is true or not. I suck at GUI, can someone tell me what is going on here?